Static or dynamic QR codes: which to use
A dynamic code can be edited later. It can also stop working. Here is the trade.
Every QR code you see is one of two kinds, and the difference matters more than the marketing around it suggests.
Static
The data is in the code. Scanning it produces exactly what was encoded, with no server in between. It works forever, cannot be tracked, and cannot be changed after printing. Everything this site makes is static.
Dynamic
The code holds a short link to somebody's service, which redirects to your real destination. You can change the destination later and see how many people scanned it. The cost is that the code only works while that service exists, keeps your account active and keeps the link alive.
When dynamic is worth it
- A campaign whose destination genuinely changes, such as a menu that moves.
- Printed material where scan counts justify a subscription.
- A code already printed in large numbers that must be repointed.
When static is the right answer
- Payments. Never put a payment through somebody else's redirect.
- WiFi, contact cards, anything with no destination to change.
- Anything printed on something permanent — a signboard, a vehicle, an engraving.
- Anything you will still want working in five years.
The failure nobody plans for
Dynamic codes go dead when a subscription lapses or a provider shuts down, and the printed material becomes waste overnight. It has happened to entire restaurant chains and to municipal signage. If the destination is not going to change, there is no reason to accept that risk.
If you do need a dynamic code, point it at a short link on a domain you own. Then the redirect is yours and nobody else can switch it off.